ADVISOR LOANOLOGY
SBA LOANS:
BUSTING THE BIGGEST MYTHS AND MOSTLY MYTHS
Equity Buy-ins Not Eligible
This is a myth as of August 2023. New rules allow for the partial equity buy-ins.
SBA Lenders Are All The Same:
Perhaps the most pervasive myth is that all SBA lenders are essentially the same since they offer SBA loans. In reality, while the underlying SBA rules are uniform, the lending institutions themselves vary widely. Each SBA lender has their unique additional qualifying criteria, policies, and requirements that they layer atop the SBA's standard rules. Furthermore, the SBA often defers to the lender’s standard policies on many requirements, which can differ significantly from lender to lender.
Takes a Lot Longer:
The notion that SBA loans inherently take longer is being debunked by platforms like FranchiseLoan.io. By connecting applicants to top lenders well-versed in SBA lending for specific industries and brands, the loan process can be expedited compared to an individual attempting to navigate it alone.
Lender Will Put a Lien on My House:
This is a widely misunderstood aspect of SBA loans. The SBA itself does not require borrowers to have equity in a property to qualify for a loan. However, an SBA lender may use such equity for collateral under certain conditions. For loans over $500k, the SBA requires home equity to be used as collateral only if the borrower has a 25% or greater equity stake in any personal property. This requirement can be avoided by taking out a Home Equity Line of Credit (HELOC), which can reduce the available equity to under 25%.
A Lot More Documentation:
While it’s true that an SBA loan may require a couple more documents than a traditional conventional loan, the total number of documents required by the SBA has actually decreased, narrowing the gap between the two.
More Ongoing Covenants :
Contrary to this belief, there are fewer ongoing covenants after an SBA loan closes than with most conventional loans. The primary post-closing requirements are the provision of an annual tax return and an updated personal financial statement.
Other M&A and Lending Myths
-
It's only the cash flow not the ROI that matters
The thinking that cash flow is all that matters is one of the more consequential myths in the industry. Just because a deal cash flows does not automatically mean it should be done, it only means it's a possibility on the table.
If it takes your current practice profits to make the acquisition deal cash flow then the deal doesn't cash flow on its own. If the deal doesn't cash flow on its own and needs your current practice's profits to contribute to the debt service payment then risk and return expectations are different.
Acquisition aggregation cash flow strategies are very different than an advisor who only intends to make only one or two opportunistic acquisitions in their career. Two totally different approaches to cash flow. See ROI box.
Cash down payment is always required
Reality: Most loans we facilitate involved no cash down payment from the borrower. Advisors who have a book of business rarely need cash down payments for acquisitions.
SBA always takes the house as collateral
Reality: Collateral requirements hinge on the borrower's equity in the property and the loan size. If the equity is less than 25% or the loan is under $500,000 then it is not required by the SBA.
Partial equity buy-ins are not eligible for SBA loans
Reality: This is a myth as of October 2023. new rules allow for the partial equity buy-ins. While conventional lending has dominated this lending purpose over the last decade, the SBA's new eligibility rules will cause a larger percentage of these deals to go SBA (with the much easier and flexible equity injection requirements).
Lenders always require some seller financing
Reality: While all lenders would "like" to have a portion of the acquisition in seller financing it isn't typically mandated, is decreasing in frequency and amount, and as long as the LTV requirements are met only are put in place by the seller's request, not the lender.
Valuation firms and M&A brokers don't get bank referral fees
Reality: We view a kickback when the client (you) is unaware of the arrangement and a referral fee when the client is aware. Some of these firms get kickbacks and some get referral fees but all get paid typically a 1% fee from the bank if you use the lender they recommend you use. That is why they recommended them.
Sellers have to receive all bank proceeds at closing
Reality: It's not uncommon for a seller to receive the payment over two or three years (without seller financing) by funding into escrow and distributing on designated future dates.
All SBA lenders handle M&A loans the same
Reality: SBA lenders vary greatly in terms of additional qualifying criteria, preferences, focus, criteria, and policies.
Multiple concurrent acquisition loans with different lenders is typical
Reality: Most lenders file a UCC-1 lien and insist on being in the first position, making concurrent loans from different lenders requires inter-creditor agreements and while it happens, it's not common and a completely case-by-case basis.
The bank approved the acquisition loan so it must be a good deal
Banks fundamentally differ from borrowers and investors in their approach to evaluating deals. While advisors are focusing on return on investment (ROI), banks rely on historical financial data rather than considering the net present value of future cash flows. Even if a bank conducts thorough underwriting and cash flow analysis, believing you will generate enough cash flow to meet your payments, they often disregard compound annual growth rate (CAGR) as a critical factor in their decision-making process, focusing solely on historical performance.
When a bank underwrites an acquisition they are not evaluating directly if this is a good investment, they are evaluating if you have the cash flow to afford it, risk, and require a business valuation to support price.
The bank doesn't need for the practice you're buying to cash flow on its own, they need for your business combined with the business you're purchasing to cash flow. If an advisor wants to acquire a practice that makes no profit but has some other value, the deal could easily cash flow because of combining with your current business. It's a deal that can get done, because it "cash flows", even though it doesn't.
Valuations are only ordered on seller's practice
Business valuations are only imperative for the seller's practice. Reality: When leveraging non-cash assets, both buyer's and seller's practices may need valuation. SBA loans have a buyer valuation for acquisition loans when there isn't a down payment required in part based on the estimated value of the buyer's business. Conventional lenders may require valuations on buyers for loans over $5 million but these polices are based on the lender.
1.75 or 1.50 DSCR is required for an SBA loan
Reality: This was LOB's old DSCR minimum and if LOB is the only SBA lender you work with then you may think their policies are identical to that of the SBA. SBA's minimum DSC is only 1.15 and LOB has dropped their DSCR to 1.50. Each lender has their own DSC minimum which can greatly impact the loan amount approved (a 50% difference in loan dollars qualified for between this 1.15 and 1.75 range).
Interest rate is the primary deciding factor in banks
Reality: It is obviously an important factor but other factors like qualifying criteria, deal structure, down payment requirements, can be more heavily weighted. If in ongoing acquisition mode amortization is much more important than rate. This is because there is not typically a night and day difference between lenders, just between SBA program loans and conventional.
Conventional loans are always better than SBA
Reality: The appropriateness of loan types varies according to the specifics of the borrower's situation and in many cases the opposite can be true. For deals where the borrower doesn't have a book SBA loans are always better from an acquisition equity injection perspective and for borrowers with and without a book this is often the most critical loan component. When buying bigger and especially much bigger SBA may offer the better scenario.
SBA loans can be refinanced readily with another SBA lender
Reality: Inter-lender refinancing of SBA loans is complex and not commonplace. However they are done sometimes, but it's not a typical thing.
Advisors can't qualify for a loan without life insurance
Reality: While this is mostly true with conventional lending to advisors SBA loans can get around this with rejection letter and documented (and acceptable) continuity plans.
Seller financing is always a good thing for the buyer
Reality: When too much is seller financed for too short of a term (for example 50% seller financed over 3 years) then the pressure on cash flow can cause the bank loan side not to qualify. However, when a seller's note term is 7 years or longer, then seller financing is almost always optimal.
The lender will always provide ongoing financing
Reality: Lender policies on additional loans for ongoing acquisitions can differ significantly. Banks who dip their toe in advisor lending may not be excited as you are about finding another great acquisition so soon after the previous one.
I read this in an article or saw it in a big study so it must be true
It may be true but it also may not be true for you. Our industry has so many different nuances, models, and terminologies for the RIA and IBD worlds and often times the distinction isn't clarified. The advice and best practices being used for multi-billion PE funded RIAs or aggregating multiple flippers, isn't always applicable or even recommended for the typical advisor who doesn't have the same resources nor in the same situation.
SBA loans involve more restrictive ongoing covenants than conventional loans
Reality: SBA loans typically require fewer ongoing covenants.
Seller financing is requisite if there is a claw-back provision
Reality: Escrow agreements have increasingly supplanted seller financing for claw-back arrangements.
Equity in the firm being acquired counts towards the SBA's equity injection requirement
Reality: Equity can count but meeting the criteria to qualify that equity is nuanced.
Borrowers directly receive acquisition funds to pay the seller
Reality: Funds are typically wired directly to the seller or held in escrow, not transferred to borrower to then be paid to seller.
Banks wont touch an advisor loan under $250K
Reality: Obtaining smaller loans, even as low as $100K, can be done through LoanBox.
Buyers "should" make a 25%-30% cash down payment on acquisitions
Reality: While M&A broker firms certainly push this and this may be their reality, this is a unicorn in our world. We believe buyers should pay the least amount as possible in a cash down payment. Any cash down payment requirement from a bank is uncommon for advisors with books of businesses.
Live Oak Bank brought SBA lending to the financial services industry
Reality: While LOB was the first to make a concentrated focus on advisor lending (AdvisorBox played a primary role in introducing them) and while LOB deserves all the pats on the back we can muster because they really did change the paradigm in advisor lending, Live Oak was only established in 2013.
Before 2013 there were 225 banks who provided 1,476 funded loans to financial advisors for a $403K average loan amount. While most loans were under $150K (1,241 of the 1,476) there were 22 SBA loans funded to advisors over $1 million prior to LOB becoming LOB. SBA lending and the wealth management industry is a decades old relationship, not a new trend.
Prior bankruptcy is an automatic denial
If you declared bankruptcy in the last three years…it isn’t a myth because it will be nearly impossible to get a lender to sign off on. And, some lenders will simply not lend to anyone with a prior bankruptcy.
But there are lenders who will make exceptions or have scenarios that will allow for lending to previous BK borrowers. Bankruptcy scenarios that can be potentially be worked around:
• If the BK is older than 10 years for some lenders.
• If the BK is older than 7 years for some lenders.
• The reasons behind the BK are important. Was it caused by a nasty divorce? Was there a serious health issue?
In all cases, if you have a prior bankruptcy a detailed letter of explanation will be required and this is something that should be prepared at the very beginning of the process.